Follow the seal with the door open
Look at the top and both side strips without pulling them out. Find places that are flattened, curled, split or missing. Pay attention to where two strips meet at a corner. Look for a section folded over by the door edge or covered by an old paint line. If a loose piece already hangs into the opening, take a photo in place. Close the door normally and note where daylight appears or where the edge still looks tight.
Show the contractor the exact shape and location
Photograph a worn spot along with a nearby section that still looks intact. Include the corner where it joins another strip and write down whether it is on the hinge side, handle side or top. Note any hard closing or springing open you noticed after earlier work. If the complaint is a draft, say whether the moving air is at that seal or close to the bottom of the door. Ask the contractor to check contact across the opening along with the condition of the strip.